Who is Jesus? Catholicism and Islam Meet in Central Park

Sacred Heart of Jesus

Sacred Heart of Jesus

“Do you want some cold water?” asked the Muslim activist calling out to me from inside his tent positioned at an entrance to Central Park in New York City.

“Sure,” I said while getting off my rented bike. “Thanks,” I muttered while taking a much needed drink on a hot July day.

“Would like a pamphlet?  We’re here to spread the true word of Islam in America.”  He smiled at me through his long beard and I was intrigued.

“Sure, religion has always interested me, what is the ‘true word’?”  My interest excited him and I guessed that most people were reluctant to approach him or take any material.

“That Islam is a religion of peace and truth,” he proudly exclaimed with a look of assurance.  He seemed excited that he was finally going to share his beliefs, all for the low price of free water.

“I actually work with a Muslim in Saudi Arabia and have read some of the Quran,” I told him. And that began an almost two hour encounter.  I remember thinking “only in New York” to have this opportunity as many consider NYC to be the most multi-cultural international mission field of any city in the world.

During our dialogue, we flushed out a few interesting beliefs; some unite and some divide us.   I’ll list a few main points he brought up and my response.

  • Jesus is respected as a prophet in the Quran, was born of the Virgin Mary and will be the one to judge the living and the dead at the end of time.  He said this to make me feel comfortable that Muslims also look to Jesus and there are chapters in the Quran written about Jesus.

Question I asked, why isn’t Muhammad the last prophet who returns?  If Jesus is the one who returns for our salvation, doesn’t this elevate him over Muhammad?

  • Jesus was replaced on the cross before he breathed his last breath since “God can’t die”.   Also, there was no empty tomb, this was a hoax and the real Jesus never rose.

Question I asked, if the Quran wasn’t written until the 7th century, how can you refute the testimony of 600 years that tie to a Christian Easter?   If Jesus was never laid to rest, how did his “body double” get out of the tomb, after all, wasn’t it recorded as empty?

  • Islam is the fastest growing religion and now has over 1 billion members worldwide, this was described as a reason it must be true.

My question, if sheer numbers ties to the truth, the Catholic Church reports over 1 billion members too but what does this tell us?

  • The Trinitarian understanding of God came as a heresy in the council of Nicaea which is why Muhammad came to clarify the true God.

My thoughts were racing, I even thought of my Mormon friend because on this objection, there are more ties to Joseph Smith and Muhammad than Jesus. My question was, why was Jesus crucified in the first place if he didn’t claim to be God?   Either he was a liar, lunatic or the Christ.

When we were done, we embraced and told each other “God bless you” and went on our way never to see each other again.   I left with a mixed feeling of satisfaction that seeds could have been planted but a feeling of disappointment that most Muslims and Christians don’t dialogue on faith.  I came to the conclusion that through mutual respect and dialogue, barriers can be broken.  Finally, I appreciated that we live in a nation that allows such encounters to take place, discussing differences with respect for each other and without conflict.


Please post your comments and questions below. We value your feedback.

If you appreciate our writing, please use both the Share and Recommend buttons to tell your family and friends about this article. Help us help others live the faith throughout their day.

Thank you! – The Editors

Print this entry

About the Author

Mike Carlton was born in Buffalo, NY. He married his college sweetheart Laurie and has six children. They were married in Ohio in 1991 and live in a suburb of Atlanta, GA. He is the son of the former NFL football star Wray Carlton. Mike currently works as the Global Vice President of MiMedx, a worldwide orthopedic biologics company in medical devices.

He graduated in 1989 from Miami University, Oxford OH with a B.S degree in Marketing and studied in the M.B.A program at Xavier University, Cincinnati OH. He earned an archdiocesan Catechetical Teaching Certificate for the Catholic Archdiocese of Atlanta in 2003.

Mike was raised Presbyterian and converted to the Catholic Church in 2002. In 2003, he started the apologetics ministry called “Why Catholic” at his parish, St. Peter Chanel, Roswell GA. In addition, Mike and Laurie help start, with Deacon Mike Bickerstaff, MAC “Marriages Are Covenants”, a ministry outreach program of the Integrated Catholic Life for married couples. He has been interviewed on the Sacred Heart Radio Program, the “Deep in Scripture” program on EWTN radio, and has been an invited guest on the “Journey Home” television program on EWTN. A popular speaker, Mike has given his conversion talk around the Archdiocese of Atlanta.

Author Archive Page

2 Comments

  1. Very good article, but I felt that it was short. I was hoping that there would be a follow up discussion in regard to shared beliefs.

    Thank you for taking the time to have such a discussion and sharing about it.

    I live in Nazareth, Israel, where for many decades Christians and Muslims lived in the same town and attended the same activities and schools.

    I’m Roman Catholic (for many generations, as we became Christians at Pentecost :-)). I grew up with several Muslims as class mates and childhood friends. We share many good values, and have many frank discussions about shared beliefs. We both reject fanaticism on both sides (as there are few fanatics on each side who give bad names to all), and respect each others religious background.

    Islam is not a terrorist religion, and I encourage people to stop looking at it that way. I will never leave the Catholic Church, but I respect the good values that my Muslim friends have.

    1. Hello Habib, thank you for your comment as you are living this everyday. I really enjoyed the discussion and you are correct, we should all reject fanatics! God bless you, Mike

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *