Catholic Cop-outs

St. Peter's Basilica

Catholic clichés are vapid.  They exhibit a lackadaisical attitude toward the faith, and consequently, the way it is taught.

Anna Mitchell, a good friend of mine and Catholic radio personality, recently took up the topic of limiting preaching to action in her December article, “Use Words When Necessary”.  I would like to toss in another classic cop-out:  the problem of emptiness that results from limiting Catholic Identity (specifically in our schools, but expanded to attitudes about Catholicism in general) to solely what are called “Gospel values”.

As a product of Catholic schools, and someone who works with many students in Catholic schools, I am forced to wonder if there is any real substance behind these “Gospel values”.

From my experience, Gospel values stem from notions of a social gospel proclaimed by Christ.  These include the need to value charity, compassion, justice, service, and so forth.  The result is an almost complete gutting of Catholic Christianity – cutting it off from the dynamism of a relationship with Christ.  “Gospel values” are no different from other ethical or philosophical traditions.  While good, do they set apart Catholic Identity from other humanistic approaches of goodwill?  Pope Benedict emphasizes this point early in Deus Caritas Est, “Being Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event, a person, which gives life a new horizon and a decisive direction.”

While values are important, they can remain airy unless they are coupled with an authentic and dynamic relationship with Christ.  Values may move a person to be a good human externally, but Christ transforms from the inside out – this is metanoia (conversion).  And, this metanoia is what is lasting precisely because it is rooted an encounter with Christ who died and rose for you, and for me, and who is calling us into relationship with him.  We are called to be disciples, crucified in Christ and no longer ourselves (Gal. 2:20).

Values tend to lack a real recognition of the gratuitous and somewhat uncomfortable redemption God offers his people throughout salvation history, up to the culmination of the cross.  God redeems, then demands a response.  Love demands a response.  This is relationship.

Planting “Gospel values” only, could be likened to planting seeds, I suppose – seeds planted in dry, highly-secularized soil, and never given any water or sunlight.  This sort of Catholicism devoid of encounter with Christ has resulted in generations of poorly-formed adults, and the pandemic abandonment of faith by young Catholics during the college years.

The Catechism actually spends very little energy explaining what values are, perhaps because they lack both a certain push and pull.  A “values-only” approach to Catholic Identity lacks the push that comes from the context of a relationship.  Any relationship of love pushes the individuals involved to self-sacrifice and gift.  Values often lack a pull, in that they fail to pull the human to anything greater than an emotive response to external situations.

Jesus says, “I have come that you may have life, and have it abundantly” (Jn. 10:10).  We have abundance of life only by entering into relationship with Christ – for he is the way, truth and life (Jn. 14:6).  Relationship with Christ, who has redeemed us, demands change – or we risk being cast out (Jn. 15:6).  Christ sends forth his disciples with the fire of the Holy Spirit not that they might preach about a nice, neat philosophy or ethical values.  They preach Christ, crucified (1 Cor. 1:23).  Dynamic Catholicism requires a personal response right now that unites the Church as one living Body.  This is Catholic identity – it is nothing other than conversion through the living Christ.  It is authentic discipleship.  Catholicism is radical, as Christ radically transformed lives, and continues to do so.


Please help us in our mission to assist readers to integrate their Catholic faith, family and work. Tell your family and friends about this article using both the Share and Recommend buttons below and via email. We value your comments and encourage you to leave your thoughts below. Thank you! – The Editors

Print this entry

About the Author

Brad is the Director of Youth Ministry for the growing youth program at St. Gertrude Parish in Cincinnati, Ohio. He is actively involved in planning, leading worship for, and speaking at retreats and youth events in the Cincinnati area. He received his BA in English and Theology from Franciscan University of Steubenville. Following his graduation in 2008, he spent a year teaching English in Denver at Bishop Machebeuf High School. Brad and his wife Katie spend much of the day chasing around their 18 month old daughter. They are expecting their second child in October. In his spare time, Brad enjoys reading classic pieces of literature, writing, playing sports, listening to classic rock, and thinking about how funny he thinks he is.

Author Archive Page

2 Comments

  1. Do you think this is why so many people say that the only important thing in life is to be a good person, and that “religion” is just a feel-good thing that helps us not be afraid of dying?

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *